Time to Pretend (29 page)

Lifting her torso, she put her hands on his shoulders so that Evan now carried her upper half. “Don’t worry, Evan. Danny might be able to fool a lot of people with his charm, but I know better than to reward this kind of behavior. I’ll let you have me first.” She did her best to kiss him given the way Danny bounced her body around.

Time to Pretend

223

They reached the top of the stairs, and Daniel turned right, strode into her bedroom, and tossed her on the bed. She bounced once before propping herself up on one elbow. Her chest rose and fell rapidly.

Desire stained her cheeks pink.

“Damn, you’re sexy.”

Evan didn’t realize he said that out loud until he heard Daniel’s chuckle. “Yeah, and she’s ours.”

Alaina crooked her finger at him. “Come kiss me, Evan.” He lost no time in shucking off his shoes. The khaki shorts and blue tee had been chosen with an eye toward looking attractive to Alaina. They were eons nicer than the cutoff jeans and faded tees he preferred. He joined her on the bed, and she drew him into her arms.

She trailed the fingertips of one hand along his cheek. When he pressed his lips against hers, she opened to him. Her soft body molded to his harder one.

Evan was vaguely aware of the bed dipping under Danny’s weight. Alaina mewed into his mouth as Daniel spooned her from behind. Evan felt like moaning when Dan’s erection ground into the hand Evan had on Alaina’s ass. He wanted to cup Daniel’s cock, grasp it in his hand as he pumped his own cock into Alaina’s body.

He knew Danny did that on purpose. It was his way of apologizing for denying the true nature of his relationship with Evan yet again.

Daniel pulled Alaina’s shoulder, breaking her kiss with Evan and rolling her onto her back. She palmed his cheek and smiled up at him.

“We’re all wearing entirely too many clothes.” Evan grinned at Daniel over her body. Within seconds, they stripped her naked. Each of them captured a nipple in their mouths.

Evan licked and sucked, nipping at her the way he knew would make her gasp.

Her leg brushed against his, the smooth skin helping to rush more blood to his cock. She arched off the bed. “This isn’t exactly what I meant.”

224

Michele Zurlo

His free hand wandered her body, coming into occasional contact with Daniel’s hand. Together, they pulled her thighs to part her legs.

Daniel moved toward her pussy. Evan watched those talented lips kiss their way across her stomach. Dan moved into position between her splayed legs, and his head dipped. The sight of his lover’s tongue licking Alaina’s sweet nether lips was much more erotic than Evan imagined. His cock throbbed so hard it hurt.

* * * *

Alaina thought she was going to die. White-hot heat seared paths around her clit. Two fingers pumped into her hole. Evan’s mouth tortured one nipple while his fingers rolled the other, sending sharp pulses of pleasure to her core. Unable to stay still, she writhed under the dual onslaught.

She had imagined this a hundred times over the course of the past week, but she was still unprepared for the havoc two lovers created.

Though they had very different styles, each of her men was a fantastic lover in his own right. Together, they were incredible, and they hadn’t even come to the good part yet.

“Don’t stop.” She was so close. Daniel’s lips closed around her clit and sucked hard. Tingling heat concentrated at her core. Her hips rose from the bed, and she cried out as she came.

Her lovers shifted. Strength returned to Alaina. That had been a starter orgasm, one to prepare her body for the pleasure to come. She jabbed her elbows into the mattress and lifted her upper body to watch Daniel and Evan undress.

The show she caught was even more erotic than she could anticipate. Evan watched as Daniel dropped his pants. The hungry look in his eye betrayed something Alaina had never guessed. Her heart went out to Evan for a brief second, and then she noticed the way Daniel paused to display his body.

Daniel not only knew Evan found him attractive, he reveled in it.

Time to Pretend

225

Alaina wanted to continue her observations to see if Daniel would stare at Evan the same way, but she yielded to some instinct telling her they didn’t want her to know yet. She hoped for “yet” because she didn’t know how long they could keep it a secret before their reasons for doing so blew up in their faces. The fallout would destroy their perfect little threesome.

Mindful of sudden movements, she let her head sink back to the mattress and closed her eyes. How long had Daniel and Evan had feelings for one another? Were they already lovers?

What were they doing with her? She didn’t doubt that both Daniel and Evan found her attractive. She might not understand it, but she didn’t doubt it. She didn’t understand why they hadn’t shared their involvement—she still wasn’t sure she could assume involvement—

when she had given them the chance. Unwilling to confront them now, she refrained from doing anything that might indicate she had noticed more than they wanted her to see.

The mattress dipped on either side of her. Alaina opened her eyes and smiled up at her lovers, favoring each of them individually. She banished the worries from her mind. Given the way they were both looking at her, they were there because they wanted to make love to her. Thank goodness she wasn’t an elaborate beard. Her heart was involved, and this meant a great deal to her. Though she wasn’t ready to admit it to either Daniel or Evan, she was in love with them both.

She couldn’t say exactly when or how it happened, but things like that didn’t matter now.

Evan’s rough fingers traced a path down her arm, leaving gooseflesh everywhere they touched and expectant skin everywhere he didn’t. “How are you, Alaina? Do you think you can get up on your hands and knees?”

She wanted to see them kiss, right there above her. Less than two feet separated their lips. Cream rushed to her already wet pussy, leaking down her crack to lubricate her ass. She was sure one of them would want to fuck her there. She wanted them both together, but she
226

Michele Zurlo

wasn’t sure she could handle it. They were both so much larger than her. Daniel’s cock was long, and while it was thick, Evan’s was even thicker. She’d never seen one so wide before.

Shoving that erotic picture away, she sat up and turned so that her bottom rested on her heels. “I’m game for anything you guys want to do.” Even as her hands encircled their hard cocks, she flashed them her best wicked grin.

Daniel sat up. He threaded his fingers through her hair, which had come loose, and held her still for a kiss. His mouth opened, and he devoured her, dazzling her with his skill and finesse. The taste and scent of her climax lingered on his lips and tongue, creating a hunger that would soon need sating.

When he broke the kiss, Alaina looked into his face to find him similarly affected. He blinked at her through half-closed bedroom eyes, and he offered no smile. All amusement had vanished, leaving only a focused, serious man behind.

He scooted back to lie down, his head resting on a pillow and his long, muscular body filling half of the space. Evan had moved behind her. One hand on her ass urged her closer to Danny.

“Touch Daniel, sweetheart. I want to watch you suck him while I fuck you from behind.” He caressed up and down her spine with his fingertips, sending waves of electricity straight to her nipples. “Are you okay with that?”

She leaned back so that his arms cradled her, and he planted a string of kisses on her neck. “Anything, Evan.” He rested his cheek on the top of her head. “You can ask for things, too, Alaina.”

She laughed lightly. Daniel closed his hand around his erection and pumped it slowly. Her breath caught. “For now, just being with both of you is what I want.”

Daniel’s hand froze. He impaled her with a hard stare. “For now?” She crawled across the narrow expanse of bed separating them.

Using one fingernail, she grazed a path along his inner thigh. “For
Time to Pretend

227

now, Danny. Later, I’m sure I’ll have a lot of requests. You know how demanding I am.” Steel was softer than her tone. She didn’t like the fact they weren’t telling her they were both bisexual and in love with each other. Not wanting to ruin the mood, she favored him with a soft smile to make up for it. “For now, I’m content with letting you call the shots.”

Before he could say anything, she bent down and licked the pearly drop of pre-cum beaded on the head of his cock. He sucked air and rested his hand on the back of her head. Giving head to Danny was something she enjoyed, and she wanted to prolong the experience.

She licked the length of him. She held him with one hand while the other caressed his sac. His hips rose from the bed, thrusting into the air, and his hand tightened in her hair. She loved him with her mouth, letting her lips wander where they pleased. She flicked her tongue over the sensitive skin of his balls before sucking one into her mouth. This wasn’t something she had ever done before, but she figured Daniel would like it.

She was right.

“Fuck, Lainie. If you keep that up, I’m going to come in your hair instead of your mouth.”

Behind her, Evan trailed kisses over her back. He was such a gentle, compassionate lover. She wondered if Daniel topped Evan or if it was the other way around. There was no telling with these two. In a lot of ways, Daniel seemed to be in charge, yet Evan had no problem calling the shots, either.

Evan’s strong hands moved her hips and legs, positioning her to receive him. She cooperated, and when she heard the foil package rip open, she finally took Daniel into her mouth. She sucked hard, pulling him in as far as she could and wrapping her hand around the base.

Her hips lifted. Evan’s fingers probed her slick opening, positioning his head at her entrance. She moaned in anticipation, and Daniel’s grip pulsed in her hair, loosening and tightening in time to the rhythm she set.

228

Michele Zurlo

One powerful thrust, and Evan filled her. Alaina made soft sounds of pleasure and need in the back of her throat, urging him to move.

Finally, he pulled out almost completely and stayed there, teasing her with the promise of more.

She glanced up at Daniel to find his gaze locked behind her, and she knew Evan was taunting Daniel as much as he was teasing her.

Daniel’s body writhed under her onslaught, and the expression on his face pleaded with Evan on her behalf.

Then Evan moved. He pumped into her, matching the rhythm she used with Daniel. Tight coils of pleasure swept her away, and Alaina forgot all about the silent communications between her lovers. When Evan slowed down, she sucked Danny slower. When he increased his pace, she matched his actions.

Noises, cries of pleasure and impending climax, came from all around Alaina. The noises Evan wrung from her were absorbed by Daniel’s rock-hard cock. In a torrent of heat, she came. Cream rushed down her thighs, her vagina milked Evan’s cock, and still he didn’t stop.

Daniel came next. Hot semen shot to the back of her throat. She swallowed it and licked him dry. He groaned beneath her.

Lifting her head, she glanced up at Daniel once more. She watched him watching Evan thrust into her body, prolonging the spirals of pleasure pulsing throughout her core. Her arms were too weak to hold her up. They trembled, a prelude to dropping her.

Evan hooked one arm under her torso and lifted her so that her back rested against his chest. He kneaded her breast, tweaking the nipple with soft pulls. Her head flopped back against his shoulder as he repositioned her legs on either side of his so that she essentially sat on his lap.

The gentle urging of Evan’s thumb on her chin had her turning her face toward him and opening for his kiss. He ravaged her, worshipping and claiming her at the same time. His hand trailed heat down her front and parted the lips of her pussy.

Time to Pretend

229

He tickled her lightly, teasing circles around her clit until she couldn’t hold in her moans anymore. Only then did he release her from the endless kiss and press the pad of his fingers against her swollen nub.

“Oh, Evan, yes. Don’t stop.”

He didn’t. Beneath her, his hips pumped, and she matched his rhythm. His stiff cock jabbed a shallow thrust into her sweet spot as his fingers created a friction designed to leave her boneless.

Alaina opened her eyes to watch Daniel watching them. Desire blazed, and it seemed to hold equal parts for Alaina and for Evan.

Having Daniel watch heightened the experience. She wanted to climax for herself. She wanted to please Evan, and she wanted to put on an unforgettable show for Danny.

Raising her arms behind her, she gripped Evan the best she could.

She needed an anchor. She needed to feel his skin and hair beneath her fingers. Control slipped, and she let it go. Her body writhed, and loud moans ripped from her chest. Even though she knew she made the sounds, they were alien to her. She felt like she was floating.

Electricity exploded, waves smashing against her from the inside, and the edges of her vision went black. Evan’s climax followed her own.

Daniel lifted her from Evan’s body and laid her on the bed next to him. The mattress dipped as Evan shifted into position on her other side. Two hot bodies cocooned her in bliss. Daniel caressed her face with a gentle reverence he’d never before displayed.

“This is right, Lainie. I wondered if I would be jealous to see the two of you together, but I’m not even close. This is perfect. The three of us belong together.” He lifted his eyes to peek over her shoulder, and she knew he was asking Evan’s opinion.

Evan’s soft, warm lips pressed to her shoulder. “I agree. We belong together.” His fingertips traced a path over her hip. “But we need a bigger bed.”

Alaina laughed softly. She agreed on both counts. Daniel faced her. She pressed her palms to his chest and touched him everywhere
230