Authors: Patrick Modiano
In the past, my mother used to say things like that, and always when I was so distraught that all I wanted to do was inhale the bottle of ether.
âYou can go and collect her laterâ¦Otherwise she'll be perfectly happy to come home by herself. Will you excuse me for a moment?'
Judging by her voice and her expression, she seemed to be somewhat upset. She disappeared in a hurry, leaving me in that room without a single chair. I was tempted to sit, like Monsieur Valadier, on the corner of the desk. It was gigantic, leather-topped, made out of light-coloured wood,
with two drawers on either side, and not a single sheet of paper or even a pencil on top. Only a telephone. Perhaps Monsieur Valadier kept his files in the drawers. My curiosity got the better of me and I opened and shut the drawers in turn. They were empty, except that at the back of one I found a few business cards with the name Michel Valadier, but the address was not in Neuilly.
Sounds of an argument were coming from upstairs. I recognised Madame Valadier's voice, and I was surprised to hear her shouting and swearing, but, every now and again, her voice became plaintive. There was the sound of a man's voice answering her. They passed in front of the doorway. Madame Valadier's voice became softer. Now they were speaking very quietly in the lobby. Then the front door banged shut and, from the window, I watched as a dark-haired, quite short young man wearing a suede jacket and a scarf headed off.
Madame Valadier came back into the study. âMy apologies for deserting youâ¦' She approached me and I could tell by her expression that she wanted to ask me something. âWould you be able to help me do some tidying up?'
She led me to the stairs and I went up to the first floor behind her. We entered a big bedroom, at the end of which
was a wide, low bed. It was the only item of furniture in the room. The bed was unmade, and there was a tray resting beside it, with two champagne glasses and an open bottle of champagne. A cork lay conspicuously in the middle of the grey carpet. The bedspread was hanging off the end of the bed. The sheets were tangled, the pillows scattered all over the bed, where a man's dressing-gown in dark-blue silk had been tossed, along with a camisole and knickers and a pair of stockings. An ashtray filled with butts was on the floor.
Madame Valadier went to open the two windows. There was a sickly smell hanging in the air, a mixture of perfume and Virginia tobacco, the smell of people who have spent a long time in the same room and the same bed.
She picked up the blue dressing-gown. âI have to put this back in my husband's wardrobe,' she said.
When she came back, she asked if I wanted to help her make the bed. She pulled up the sheets and blanket. Her movements were abrupt and rapid, as if she was frightened of being caught out by someone, and I had trouble keeping up with her. She hid the lingerie and stockings under a pillow. As we finished straightening the bedspread, she caught sight of the tray.
âOh, yes, I'd forgotten about thatâ¦'
She picked up the bottle of champagne and the two glasses and opened a wardrobe where lots of pairs of shoes were lined up on shelves. I had never seen so many shoes: different-coloured court shoes, ballerina flats, bootsâ¦She shoved the bottle and glasses at the back of the top shelf and shut the wardrobe. She looked like someone rushing to hide compromising evidence before the police arrived. All that was left now were the ashtray and the champagne cork. I picked them up. She took them out of my hands and went into the bathroom. The door was open and I heard the noise of the toilet flushing.
She looked at me strangely. She wanted to say something, but she didn't have time. Through the open windows, we could hear a diesel engine. She leaned out one of the windows. I was right behind her. Down below, Monsieur Valadier was getting out of a taxi. He was carrying an overnight bag and a black leather briefcase.
When we went down to join him, he was already on the phone, sitting on his desk, and he greeted us with a wave. Then he hung up. Madame Valadier asked him if his trip had gone well.
âNot great, Véra.'
She shook her head, absorbed. âBut you're not worried, are you?'
âOverall, things are fine, but there are still a few sticking points.'
He turned to me and smiled. âIsn't she at school today?'
He was referring to his daughter, but I got the impression that he wasn't really interested and that he was merely asking out of politeness to me.
âI let her stay at school with the boarders,' said Madame Valadier.
Monsieur Valadier took off his navy-blue coat and placed it on his overnight bag, on the floor by the desk.
âYou know, she can just as easily come home by herselfâ¦' He spoke softly, still smiling at me. He had the same attitude as his wife.
âThere's something we want to discuss with you about our daughter,' said Madame Valadier. âShe'd like to have a dog.'
Monsieur Valadier was still sitting on the corner of his desk. He was swinging one leg in a steady rhythm. Where on earth could people sit if they came to meet him in this office? I wondered. Although I was pretty sure that no one ever came here.
âYou'll have to explain to her that it's not possible,' Véra Valadier said. She seemed aghast at the idea that a dog might turn up in the house. âWill you tell her later?'
She looked so anxious that I couldn't help myself from saying, âYes, madame.'
She smiled at me. That had clearly taken a load off her mind.
âI've already asked you to call me Véra, not madame.'
She was standing next to her husband, leaning against the desk.
âIn fact, it would be much simpler if you just called us Véra and Michel.'
Her husband was smiling at me, too. There they were, across the room, with their smooth, unlined faces, still quite young.
For me, the evil curse and the bad memories all centred on one face, that of my mother. The little girl had to contend with these two individuals whose smiles and smooth skin were of the kind we're sometimes shocked to see on the faces of murderers who have long remained unpunished.
Monsieur Valadier removed a cigarillo from the top pocket of his jacket and lit it with his lighter. He took a puff and exhaled thoughtfully.
âI'm counting on you to sort out this dog business.'
I saw the little girl at once. She was sitting on the bench, reading a magazine. Around her, twenty or so older girls were scattered about the schoolyard. The boarders. She wasn't paying them the slightest attention, as if she had been waiting there all day without any idea why. She seemed surprised that I had come to collect her so early.
We went down Rue de la Ferme.
âWe don't have to go home straightaway,' she said.
We had reached the end of the street and we set off into the section of the Bois de Boulogne where there are pine trees. It was odd to be walking on a late-November afternoon among trees that were reminiscent of summer and the sea. When I was her age, I didn't want to go home either. And could you even call it a home, that gigantic apartment where I had ended up with my mother, without it ever being clear to me why she was living there? The first time she took me there, I thought it belonged to some friends of hers, and I was surprised when the two of us stayed the nightââI'm going to show you your room,' she announced. And I was
anxious when I had to go to bed. In that big empty room with the oversized bed, I expected someone to come and ask me what I was doing there. It was as if I had intuited that my mother and I were not really supposed to be on the premises.
âHave you been living in that house for long?' I asked the little girl.
She had been there at the beginning of the year. But she couldn't remember exactly where she was living before that. What had struck me, the first time I went to the Valadier house, were all those empty rooms, which reminded me of the apartment where I'd lived with my mother when I was the same age as the little girl. I recalled that, in the kitchen, there was a board stuck on the wall, with white panels that lit up, the words in black lettering:
DINING ROOM, STUDY
and so on. I also recalled the words
CHILDREN'S BEDROOM
. Who could those children possibly be? They were probably going to come back at any moment and ask me why I was in their bedroom.
It was dusk and the little girl was still keen to delay our return. We had headed off in the other direction from her parents' home. But was it really their home? Twelve years on, who still knew, for example, that my mother had also
lived in Avenue Malakoff, very near the Bois de Boulogne? That apartment didn't belong to us. I found out later that my mother was staying there while the owner was away. Frédérique and one of her women friends talked about it one evening at Fossombronne-la-Fôret, over dinner, when I was at the table. Certain words stick in children's minds and, even if they don't understand them at the time, they understand them twenty years later. It's a bit like the grenades we were told to watch out for at Fossombronne-la-Fôret. Apparently, ever since the war, there were one or two buried in Kraut's Field, and there was still a chance they could explode after all this time.
Yet another reason to be frightened. But we couldn't resist slipping out to that overgrown vacant block and playing hide-and-seek. Frédérique had gone to the apartment to try to find something my mother had forgotten when she left.
We had arrived at the edge of the little lake where people came to ice-skate in winter. The twilight was beautiful. The trees were outlined against a blue and pink sky.
âSo, you'd like a dog.'
She was embarrassed, as if I had revealed her secret.
âYour parents told me.'
She frowned and pursed her lips, pouting. âThey don't want a dog,' she said.
âI'm going to try to speak to them about it. They'll come round sooner or later.'
She smiled at me. She seemed to trust me. She believed that I'd be able to persuade Véra and Michel Valadier. But I was under no illusion about those two: they were as tough as the Kraut. I had suspected as much from the beginning. With Véra, it was immediately obvious. She had a fake first name. And, in my opinion, his name wasn't Michel Valadier, either. He must have already gone by several other names. And, indeed, there was a different address on his business card. I wondered if he wasn't even more devious and more dangerous than his wife.
Now we had to head home, and I was regretting my empty promise to her. We were walking along the riding tracks to get back to the Jardin d'Acclimatation. I was certain that Véra and Michel Valadier wouldn't give in.
He opened the front door and went straight back to his study on the ground floor, without saying a word to us. I heard gales of raucous, vicious laughter. Madame ValadierâVéraâwas yelling, but I couldn't make out what she was
saying. Their voices were indistinguishable, each trying to shout over the top of the other. The little girl opened her eyes wide. She was frightened, but I sensed that she was used to this fear. In the lobby, she stood still, frozen; I should have taken her off somewhere else. But where? Madame Valadier came out of the study, looking calm and composed.
âDid you have a nice walk?' she asked.
Once again, she looked like those cold, mysterious blondes who glide through old American movies. Then Monsieur Valadier came out. He was also very calm. He was wearing an elegant black suit and there were big scratches down one of his cheeks, most likely from fingernails. Véra Valadier's fingernails? She kept hers rather long. The two of them were standing next to each other in the doorway, with their smooth faces of murderers who would remain unpunished, for lack of evidence. It looked as if they were posing for a photo, not for an official identity shot but for the cameras at the beginning of a soirée, as the guests arrive.
âDid mademoiselle explain about the dog?' asked Véra Valadier. Her tone was distant, not at all like the voices you hear around Rue de Douai, where she'd told me she was born. With another first name.
âDogs are sweet,' she said. âBut they're very dirty.'
âYour maman is right,' Michel Valadier added, in the same tone as his wife. âIt would really not be a good idea to have a dog in the house.'
âWhen you're a big girl, you'll be able to have all the dogs you likeâ¦But not here and not now.'
Véra Valadier's voice had changed. She sounded bitter. Perhaps she was imagining a time in the futureâtime passes so quicklyâwhen her daughter would be grown up and when she, Véra, would roam the corridors of the metro forever and ever, in a yellow coat.
The little girl didn't say a thing. She merely stared, wide-eyed.
âYou see, with dogs you get diseases,' Monsieur Valadier said. âAnd, well, they bite, too.'
Now he had a shifty look and an odd way of speaking, like an illegal street peddler keeping an eye out for the police.
I was finding it hard to remain quiet. I would gladly have stood up for the little girl, but I didn't want the conversation to get poisonous and for her then to get scared. Nevertheless, I couldn't stop myself from looking Michel Valadier straight in the eye. âDid you hurt yourself, sir?'