Only Between Us (6 page)

I shrug. “I don’t know. I mean, I felt like I got a lot out of it, but …” I spent six months in therapy, and it was definitely helpful. But I don’t want to feel broken anymore.

“What else are you doing for yourself? How are you spending your free time?”

If anyone else asked me this, I’d push back. But Dr. Greer could yank me from my internship if he senses I can’t handle it, and I need to convince him I can. “I’m painting, actually. Taking a class at the co-op. Jude is doing it with me.”

He grins. “You paint?”

“I did, but I hadn’t in a while. I’m giving it another try.”

“Art is a wonderful therapeutic outlet,” he says, and I can tell he’s pleased. “I’m glad you’re taking self-care seriously. Good therapists know how to nurture themselves so they can truly be there for others.”

I swallow the lump in my throat. “I know. I’m trying. I-I mean—”

“It’s all right,” he assures me. “I simply wanted to check in with you. I hope you don’t mind.”

“No, I appreciate it.” I stand up, eager to escape. “I have another class.”

He waves toward the door, still smiling. “Don’t let me keep you. I’ll see you next week. I look forward to hearing more about your painting class.”

A pair of wolf-gray eyes flashes in my mind, along with the memory of heat and the deep vibrations of Caleb’s voice. I let out a shaky, surprised laugh that causes Dr. Greer’s eyebrows to rise to the middle of his forehead.

My cheeks blazing, I say goodbye and scoot out of there as fast as my legs will carry me.

One more minute of this film and I’m going to claw my own eyes out. There’s little dialogue, and what’s said is in Icelandic, and it’s trying way too hard to be artsy—but to me it just looks cheesy. “Eric, I’m stepping out,” I whisper. “I’ll meet you guys out front when it’s over, okay?”

He looks down at me. “What’s wrong?”

“This one’s not for me, unfortunately. I’m fine, though. I’ll see you in a bit.”

Jude leans around Eric. “You want me to come with you?”

I shake my head. His hand is entwined with Eric’s, and I think they could use the time alone. They’re always inviting me places, but being the third wheel gets old. I get to my feet and edge my way to the aisle, trying not to stumble. The film festival draws hundreds, maybe thousands, every year, but the flicks are hit or miss. When I reach the lobby I feel like I’m surfacing after too long underwater.

The guy at the ticket counter gives me a look. “More people have walked outta that film than any other.”

“I’m not asking for my money back. No worries.”

He looks relieved. “Thanks. And sorry.”

“When’s it scheduled to end?”

He looks at his watch. “About ninety minutes to go. It’s a long one.”

Good Lord. I’m glad I left. I thank him and head for the door. The crisp evening air is exhilarating. I walk briskly up the street, taking in the window displays, heading for Lake Park a few blocks up, where I can sit by the water and enjoy the sound of the waves lapping against the retaining walls.

As I pass the drug store, a tall guy wearing a beanie and carrying a small plastic bag strides out, the bell clattering against the glass door as it shuts behind him. And when I see his angular face in profile …

“Caleb?”

He spins around quickly and his eyes go wide when he sees me. His fist clenches over the plastic bag. “Romy. Hey. I … hi.”

“Hi,” I say with a laugh. “How are you?”

His startled expression softens a bit. “I’m all right.” He looks over my shoulder and frowns. “You alone?”

“I left some friends at the film festival.” I wrinkle my nose.

“Are you escaping from the movie—or the company?” he asks. He shoves the plastic bag in the pocket of his jacket.

“Oh, the movie. It’s called
Sorg
.”

“What?” he asks, his lips twitching upward. “It sounds like a bad sci-fi.”

His bemused look is utterly adorable, and I find myself grinning. “I think
Sorg
is Icelandic for
trying too hard
.”

He snorts. “So you’ve fled from the movie theater to wander the streets.”

“Only for another ninety minutes.”

He pulls out his phone and checks the time. “It’s nearly midnight. You sure that’s safe?”

I rub my arms, suddenly cold. “I guess … maybe not.”

His gaze is on my face. So intense I can feel it. “I could keep you company for a while. If you want.”

Is he serious? Does he actually want to, or is he simply being nice? Because it’s probably the latter, I wave him off. “That’s okay. I’m sure you have somewhere to be.”

He winces. “I wouldn’t mind putting it off for a while.”

Now I’m the one staring. He’s shaved off all the stubble, so his cheeks are smooth, and I notice the tiniest of dimples in his chin. I suddenly want to poke it with my finger, to see what it would feel like. “All right,” I say. “If you don’t mind being waylaid.”

He gives me a rueful look. “Coffee?”

I inhale a sharp breath. Caleb’s own words echo in my head.
You sure that’s safe?

No
. “Yeah,” I say. “That sounds perfect.”

Chapter Six: Caleb

What the hell am I doing?

The box of condoms in my pocket feels huge and heavy, and even though Romy can’t possibly know they’re there, somehow I’m convinced I’m going to give it away.

And yet, I asked her out for coffee.

Somewhere, in a mansion on the north end of town, right by the water, Claudia Dexter is waiting for me. I’m already late. She’s expecting me to arrive at any moment. But here I am.

With Romy. A jittery feeling tingles in my chest. She walks by my side, closing her eyes every time the breeze ruffles her hair. I’m tempted to offer her my cap, but that would be weird. “So … did you get anything done Wednesday night after I left?” I ask. I know what Daniel told me, but I want to hear it from her.

She gives me a sidelong glance and then looks away quickly. “I did, actually. I really appreciated the guidance.” She pulls her lacy cardigan around her, tight over her breasts. I have to tear my eyes away.

“You’re really good at teaching,” she says quietly.

How does she do that? Make me feel like I’m worth something? “Thanks. I enjoy it most of the time.”

“Most of the time?”

I shrug, thinking about Claudia and what awaits me tonight. Her husband left on a business trip this afternoon. I met him on Thursday. He lumbered in while Claudia had me in the gallery room, and I shook the guy’s hand with gratitude, because she was about to make her move. He said he looked forward to seeing my work. He actually seemed like a nice guy. Either he has no idea his wife wants to get in my pants, or he doesn’t care. My stomach tightens. “I think it depends on what people want to get out of the class. People come for all sorts of reasons.”

“And that affects your enjoyment of teaching?” She’s staring straight ahead, at the white lights shimmering on the lake a few blocks up. I can see the water through the trees at the edge of the park. I’m realizing there’s no coffee place open this late, but for some reason, I’m hoping Romy hasn’t figured it out yet.

“It does sometimes,” I tell her. “I like teaching students who want to be there for the joy of it. Kids are like that.”

“You teach kids’ classes?”

“After-school classes. A lot of them walk right over from the middle school. And I teach classes for little kids on weekends.” I smile. “It’s messy as hell, but so much fun. They really get into it.”

She pulls her eyes from the water and looks up at me. “How do we forget that?”

“Forget what?” I stare into the deep green, heavy on the blue, light on the yellow, except for this little circle right around the edge of her pupils. Golden brown. We’re standing under a street lamp. I can see every detail.

“How to lose ourselves in the joy of something,” she explains. “Adults can’t do that as easily as kids can. At some point, we forget how.”

“I think
when
you forget that depends on who you are. Maybe some people never do.” I tug on the edge of my cap, pulling it a little lower on my forehead as we reach the end of Main Street. The bag in my pocket crinkles. “I don’t know anyone like that, though. Daniel probably comes closest.”

“I can see that. I’m kind of jealous. Sometimes I want to lose myself like that. I’d like to remember how.”

“Yeah?” Suddenly, I’m imagining what she might look like, lost in the joy of … something.

She glances up at me and bites her lip, and it takes all I have not to run my thumb along the edge of her mouth. She’s not wearing lipstick. Her lips are crimson red and titanium white and the tiniest hint of cadmium yellow, blended perfectly into this pink so delicate that I want to taste it and—

“Want to go sit by the lake?” she blurts.

“Sure.”

We cross the street and head along the sidewalk to the benches that line the boardwalk right by the water. She’s wearing a long skirt that flutters around her ankles as she walks, revealing open-toed shoes. Bare feet, painted toenails peeking out at me. I wonder if she’s cold, but I don’t ask because I don’t want to give her any reason to leave. “So what’s
your
reason for coming to my class?” I ask as we sit on a bench right under a decorative street lamp, nice and bright. Safe.

She pulls her sweater around her again. I should offer her my jacket, but there’s a goddamn box of rubbers in my pocket, and for some reason, I desperately don’t want her to know that. This is like the definition of lose-lose. I’m trying to figure out if I can chuck the whole bag in the trashcan next to me without her noticing when she says, “I signed up for the class because I missed painting. It was part of me and I lost it. I wanted it back.”

Her words freeze my stupid thoughts in place. “How did you lose it?”

As soon as I say it, I know it’s the wrong question. It’s like I can see her gates slamming shut, being reinforced from within. Her fingers curl into the thin fabric of her cardigan. “Or maybe I gave it away,” she murmurs, then shakes herself. “I just got busy with school.”

Now she’s lying. I can tell. Her voice is all breezy-easy. Katie does that sometimes, but she never fools me. Still, I know what it means—
back off
. “Fair enough. You should take the advanced oil techniques class I’m starting up, though. I think you’d find it more interesting.”

She gives me a hesitant smile. “When is it? I didn’t see it on the online schedule.”

That’s because it wasn’t on there. I decided to start the class ten seconds ago. “Uh … I’ll have to check …”

“I have a class on Monday nights.”

“It’s definitely not on Monday nights.”

She laughs, and I slide my arm along the bench behind her because I’m insane. As soon as I do it, she goes very still, and those dark green eyes land on my face. “When you figure it out, let me know when it is,” she says. Her expression is cautious and hopeful and challenging and scared and hot, all at once. “I might switch.”

There’s a freckle on her right cheekbone, the exact shade of dark brown sugar. I imagine tasting it, and my muscles pull tight. “It might be a small class.” Maybe just her and me.

“I’m sure there are plenty of students who’d be eager to sign up,” she says, and by her tentative smile and the curious sweep of her gaze, I know she’s noticed Claudia and her friends, how they look at me. My jaw tenses as I remember where I’m supposed to be right now.

  “How’s your painting coming?” Romy asks.

I should be relieved that she changed the subject, but for some reason, thinking of my painting only reminds me of the way Claudia looked at it. “I’m struggling with it.”

“The whole thing looked like a struggle,” she says, pretty much summing up my entire life. “That was why I liked it.”

“You’re in a very small minority.” I force a chuckle. “I don’t have a style people want to look at. One of my professors told me that last May, right before I graduated.”

Her mouth drops open. “What a terrible thing to say! Besides … I wanted to look at it. I thought it was honest and brave, and it made me uncomfortable, and maybe that’s good for people sometimes. It means they’re still capable of reacting to something. It means they’re not numb.” She bows her head. “It’s not good to be numb,” she murmurs, almost to herself, and then she looks up again, her words coming out in a rush. “And you paint things that make people feel. They might feel bad or sad or disgusted, but that’s better than apathy. Not every artist can get a visceral reaction out of people.”

I stare at her in awe, knowing I shouldn’t take her words too seriously; it would hurt too much if she didn’t mean them. My heart is beating like a jackhammer. I could go a few different ways with this, but only one path is safe. I plaster on my best casual smile. “If only you owned one of the galleries downtown, all my problems would be solved,” I say. Breezy-easy. If there’s one thing I know how to do, it’s keeping things from going too deep.

Romy’s so still, so somber. Like she’s looking right into my mind, right past all my bullshit. The joking smile slides off my face, too heavy to hold in place.

“I’m sorry it’s been such a struggle for you,” she says quietly. “I think you’re really talented.”

“You look cold,” I blurt. Her teeth are starting to chatter. I’d be a selfish asshole if I didn’t say something, right? I’m not avoiding this conversation—I’m merely pointing out the obvious. I want to unzip my jacket and invite her inside. My fingers play with the tab on my chest.

Romy watches my nervous movements as I stare at her throat, the slope of her neck. “I don’t mind,” she says. “I like it out here.”

Am I imagining that she’s leaning a little closer? The thought sends a scorching wave of heat through my body. My arm tilts off the edge of the bench, touching her back. If she shows the slightest sign of discomfort, I’m backing off. Regardless of what she said, there are some situations where being uncomfortable is not a good thing at all.

But she scoots in, seeking me out. It’s like a fucking miracle. My fingers are
almost
steady as I trace the edge of her hair along her forehead. She closes her eyes when my fingertips skim along her face. Her hair is so short, but I like it, because I can see the line of her jaw and the smooth plane of her brow. I should say something to her, about how I think she’s beautiful, about how I don’t know her but want to, but not a single word makes it past the torrent of sensation. Her lips look so soft, and the longer I stare at them, the harder I get. She smells incredible, a warm, subtle, clean kind of scent, so faint that she has to be close to pick it up. And I want her close. Closer than this.