Rage of Angels (15 page)

“What can I do for you?” Roger Davis asked.

“As I explained on the telephone, I’m here on behalf of Loretta Marshall.”

He looked at her and said impatiently, “So?”

“She’s asked me to institute a paternity suit against Mr. Curtis Randall III. I would prefer not to do that.”

“You’d be a damned fool if you did.”

Jennifer held her temper in check. “We don’t wish to drag your client’s name through the courts. As I’m sure you know, this kind of case always gets nasty. Therefore, we’re prepared to accept a reasonable out-of-court settlement.”

Roger Davis gave Jennifer a wintry smile. “I’m sure you are. Because you have no case. None at all.”

“I think we have.”

“Miss Parker, I haven’t time to mince words. Your client is a whore. She’ll have intercourse with anything that moves. I have a list of men she’s slept with. It’s as long as my arm. You think
my
client is going to get hurt? Your client will be
destroyed.
She’s a schoolteacher, I believe. Well, when I get through with her she’ll never teach anywhere again as long as she lives. And I’ll tell you something else. Randall believes he’s the father of that baby. But you’ll never prove it in a million years.”

Jennifer sat back, listening, her face expressionless.

“Our position is that your client could have become impregnated by anyone in the Third Army. You want to make a deal? Fine. I’ll tell you what we’ll do. We’ll buy your client birth-control pills so that it doesn’t happen again.”

Jennifer stood up, her cheeks burning. “Mr. Davis,” she said, “that little speech of yours is going to cost your client half a million dollars.”

And Jennifer was out the door.

Ken Bailey and three assistants could turn up nothing against Curtis Randall III. He was a widower, a pillar of
society, and he had had very few sexual flings.

“The son of a bitch is a born-again puritan,” Ken Bailey complained.

They were seated in the conference room at midnight, the night before the paternity trial was to begin. “I’ve talked to one of the attorneys in Davis’s office, Jennifer. They’re going to destroy our client. They’re not bluffing.”

“Why are you sticking your neck out for this girl?” Dan Martin asked.

“I’m not here to judge her sex life, Dan. She believes that Curtis Randall is the father of her baby. I mean, she really
believes
it. All she wants is money for her daughter—nothing for herself. I think she deserves her day in court.”

“We’re not thinking about her,” Ken replied. “We’re thinking about you. You’re on a hot roll. Everybody’s watching you. I think this is a no-win case. It’s going to be a black mark against you.”

“Let’s all get some sleep,” Jennifer said. “I’ll see you in court.”

The trial went even worse than Ken Bailey had predicted. Jennifer had had Loretta Marshall bring her baby into the courtroom, but now Jennifer wondered if she had not made a tactical error. She sat there, helpless, as Roger Davis brought witness after witness to the stand and forced each of them to admit they had slept with Loretta Marshall. Jennifer did not dare cross-examine them. They were victims, and they were testifying in public only because they had been forced to. All Jennifer could do was sit by while her client’s name was besmirched. She watched the faces of the jurors, and she could read the growing hostility there. Roger Davis was too clever to characterize Loretta Marshall as a whore. He did not have to. The people on the stand did it for him.

Jennifer had brought in her own character witnesses to
testify to the good work that Loretta Marshall had done as a teacher, to the fact that she attended church regularly and was a good mother; but all this made no impression in the face of the horrifying array of Loretta Marshall’s lovers. Jennifer had hoped to play on the sympathy of the jury by dramatizing the plight of a young woman who had been betrayed by a wealthy playboy and then abandoned when she had become pregnant. The trial was not working out that way.

Curtis Randall III was seated at the defendant’s table. He could have been chosen by a casting director. He was an elegant-looking man in his late fifties, with striking gray hair and tanned, regular features. He came from a social background, belonged to all the right clubs and was wealthy and successful. Jennifer could feel the women on the jury mentally undressing him.

Sure,
Jennifer thought.
They’re thinking that they’re worthy to go to bed with Mr. Charming, but not that what-does-he-see-in-her slut sitting in the courtroom with a ten-month old baby in her arms.

Unfortunately for Loretta Marshall, the child looked nothing like its father. Or its mother, for that matter. It could have belonged to anybody.

As though reading Jennifer’s thoughts, Roger Davis said to the jury, “There they sit, ladies and gentlemen, mother and child. Ah! But
whose
child? You’ve seen the defendant. I defy anyone in this courtroom to point out
one single point of resemblance
between the defendant and this infant. Surely, if my client were the father of this child, there would be
some
sign of it. Something in the eyes, the nose, the chin. Where is that resemblance? It doesn’t exist, and for a very simple reason. The defendant is not the father of this child. No, I’m very much afraid that what we have here is the classic
example of a loose woman who was careless, got pregnant, and then looked around to see which lover could best afford to pay the bills.”

His voice softened. “Now, none of us is here to judge her. What Loretta Marshall chooses to do with her personal life is her own business. The fact that she is a teacher and can influence the minds of small children, well, that is not in my purview, either. I am not here to moralize; I’m simply here to protect the interests of an innocent man.”

Jennifer studied the jury and she had the sinking feeling that every one of them was on the side of Curtis Randall. Jennifer still believed Loretta Marshall. If only the baby looked like its father! Roger Davis was right. There was no resemblance at all. And he had made sure the jury was aware of that.

Jennifer called Curtis Randall to the stand. She knew that this was her only chance to try to repair the damage that had been done, her final opportunity to turn the case around. She studied the man in the witness chair for a moment.

“Have you ever been married, Mr. Randall?”

“Yes. My wife died in a fire.” There was an instinctive reaction of sympathy from the jury.

Damn
! Jennifer moved on quickly. “You never remarried?”

“No. I loved my wife very much, and I—”

“Did you and your wife have any children?”

“No. Unfortunately, she was not able to.”

Jennifer gestured toward the baby. “Then Melanie is your only—”

“Objection!”

“Sustained. Counsel for the plaintiff knows better than that.”

“I’m sorry, Your Honor. It slipped out.” Jennifer turned back to Curtis Randall. “Do you like children?”

“Yes, very much.”

“You’re the chairman of the board of your own corporation, are you not, Mr. Randall?”

“Yes.”

“Haven’t you ever wished for a son to carry on your name?”

“I suppose every man wants that.”

“So if Melanie had been born a boy instead of—”

“Objection!”

“Sustained.” The judge turned to Jennifer. “Miss Parker, I will ask you again to stop doing that.”

“Sorry, Your Honor.” Jennifer turned back to Curtis Randall. “Mr. Randall, are you in the habit of picking up strange women and taking them to hotels?”

Curtis Randall ran his tongue nervously over his lower lip. “No, I am not.”

“Isn’t it true that you first met Loretta Marshall in a bar and took her to a hotel room?”

His tongue was working at his lips again. “Yes, ma’am, but that was just—that was just sex.”

Jennifer stared at him. “You say ‘that was just sex’ as though you feel sex is something dirty.”

“No, ma’am.” His tongue flicked out again.

Jennifer was watching it, fascinated, as it moved across his lips. She was filled with a sudden, wild sense of hope. She knew now what she had to do. She had to keep pushing him. And yet she could not push him so hard that the jury would become antagonistic toward her.

“How many women have you picked up in bars?”

Roger Davis was on his feet. “Irrelevant, Your Honor. And I object to this line of questioning. The only woman involved in this case is Loretta Marshall. We have already stipulated that the defendant had sexual intercourse with her. Aside from that, his personal life has no relevance in this courtroom.”

“I disagree, Your Honor. If the defendant is the kind of man who—”

“Sustained. Please discontinue that line of questioning, Miss Parker.”

Jennifer shrugged. “Yes, Your Honor.” She turned back to Curtis Randall. “Let’s get back to the night you picked up Loretta Marshall in a bar. What kind of bar was it?”

“I—I really don’t know. I’d never been there before.”

“It was a singles bar, wasn’t it?”

“I have no idea.”

“Well, for your information, the
Play Pen
was and is a singles bar. It has the reputation of being a pickup place, a rendezvous where men and women go to meet partners they can take to bed. Isn’t that why you went there, Mr. Randall?”

Curtis Randall began to lick his lips again. “It—it may have been. I don’t remember.”

“You don’t remember?” Jennifer’s voice was weighted with sarcasm. “Do you happen to remember the date on which you first met Loretta Marshall in that bar?”

“No, I don’t. Not exactly.”

“Then let me refresh your memory.”

Jennifer walked over to the plaintiff’s table and began looking through some papers. She scribbled a note as though she were copying a date and handed it to Ken Bailey. He studied it, a puzzled expression on his face.

Jennifer moved back toward the witness box. “It was on January eighteenth, Mr. Randall.”

Out of the corner of her eye, Jennifer saw Ken Bailey leaving the courtroom.

“It could have been, I suppose. As I said, I don’t remember.”

For the next fifteen minutes, Jennifer went on questioning Curtis Randall. It was a rambling, gentle cross-examination, and Roger Davis did not interrupt, because he saw that Jennifer was making no points with the jurors, who were beginning to look bored.

Jennifer kept talking, keeping an eye out for Ken Bailey.
In the middle of a question, Jennifer saw him hurry into the courtroom, carrying a small package.

Jennifer turned to the judge. “Your Honor, may I ask for a fifteen-minute recess?”

The judge looked at the clock on the wall. “Since it’s almost time for lunch, the court will adjourn until one-thirty.”

At one-thirty the court was in session again. Jennifer had moved Loretta Marshall to a seat closer to the jury box, with the baby on her lap.

The judge said, “Mr. Randall, you are still under oath. You will not have to be sworn in again. Take the stand, please.”

Jennifer watched as Curtis Randall sat down in the witness box. She walked up to him and said, “Mr. Randall, how many illegitimate children have you sired?”

Roger Davis was on his feet. “Objection! This is outrageous, Your Honor. I will not have my client subjected to this kind of humiliation.”

The judge said, “Objection sustained.” He turned to Jennifer. “Miss Parker, I have warned you—”

Jennifer said contritely, “I’m sorry, Your Honor.”

She looked at Curtis Randall and saw that she had accomplished what she had wanted. He was nervously licking his lips. Jennifer turned toward Loretta Marshall and her baby. The baby was busily licking its lips. Jennifer slowly walked over to the baby and stood in front of her a long moment, focusing the attention of the jury.

“Look at that child,” Jennifer said softly.

They were all staring at little Melanie, her pink tongue licking her underlip.

Jennifer turned and walked back to the witness box. “And look at this man.”

Twelve pairs of eyes turned to focus on Curtis Randall. He sat there nervously licking his underlip, and suddenly the resemblance was unmistakable. Forgotten was the fact that
Loretta Marshall had slept with dozens of other men. Forgotten was the fact that Curtis Randall was a pillar of the community.

“This is a man,” Jennifer said mournfully, “of position and means. A man everyone looks up to. I want to ask you only one question: What kind of man is it who would deny his own child?”

The jury was out less than one hour, returning with a judgment for the plaintiff. Loretta Marshall would receive two hundred thousand dollars in cash and two thousand dollars a month for child support.

When the verdict came in, Roger Davis strode up to Jennifer, his face flushed with anger. “Did you do something with that baby?”

“What do you mean?”

Roger Davis hesitated, unsure of himself. “That lip thing. That’s what won the jury over, the baby licking her lips like that. Can you explain it?”

“As a matter of fact,” Jennifer said loftily, “I can. It’s called heredity.” And she walked away.

Jennifer and Ken Bailey disposed of the bottle of corn syrup on the way back to the office.

Adam Warner had known from almost the beginning that his marriage to Mary Beth had been a mistake. He had been impulsive and idealistic, trying to protect a young girl who seemed lost and vulnerable to the world.

He would give anything not to hurt Mary Beth, but Adam was deeply in love with Jennifer. He needed someone to talk to, and he decided on Stewart Needham. Stewart had always been sympathetic. He would understand Adam’s position.

The meeting turned out to be quite different from what Adam had planned. As Adam walked into Stewart Needham’s office, Needham said, “Perfect timing. I’ve just been on the phone with the election committee. They’re formally asking you to run for the United States Senate. You’ll have the full backing of the party.”

“I—that’s wonderful,” Adam said.

“We have a lot to do, my boy. We have to start organizing things. I’ll set up a fund-raising committee. Here’s where I think we should begin…”

For the next two hours, they discussed plans for the campaign.

When they had finished, Adam said, “Stewart, there’s something personal I’d like to talk to you about.”

“I’m afraid I’m late for a client now, Adam.”

And Adam had the sudden feeling that Stewart Needham had known what was on Adam’s mind all the while.

Adam had a date to meet Jennifer for lunch at a dairy restaurant on the West Side. She was waiting for him in a rear booth.

Adam walked in, charged with energy, and from his expression Jennifer knew that something had happened.

“I have some news for you,” Adam told her. “I’ve been asked to run for the United States Senate.”

“Oh, Adam!” Jennifer was filled with a sudden excitement. “That’s wonderful! You’ll make such a great senator!”

“The competition’s going to be fierce. New York’s a tough state.”

“It doesn’t matter. No one can stop you.” And Jennifer knew it was true. Adam was intelligent and courageous, willing to fight the battles he believed in. As he had once fought her battle.

Jennifer took his hand and said warmly, “I’m so proud of you, darling.”

“Easy, I haven’t been elected yet. You’ve heard about cups, lips and slips.”

“That has nothing to do with my being proud of you. I love you so much, Adam.”

“I love you, too.”

Adam thought about telling Jennifer of the discussion he had almost had with Stewart Needham, but he decided not to. It could wait until he had straightened things out.

“When will you start campaigning?”

“They want me to announce that I’m running right away. I’ll have unanimous party backing.”

“That’s wonderful!”

There was something that was
not
wonderful tugging at the back of Jennifer’s mind. It was something she did not want to put into words, but she knew that sooner or later she was going to have to face it. She wanted Adam to win, but the Senate race would be a sword of Damocles hanging over her head. If Adam won, Jennifer would lose him. He would be running on a reform ticket and there would be no margin in his life for any scandal. He was a married man and if it was learned he had a mistress, it would be political suicide.

That night, for the first time since she had fallen in love with Adam, Jennifer had insomnia. She was awake until dawn battling the demons of the night.

Cynthia said, “There’s a call waiting for you. It’s the Martian again.”

Jennifer looked at her blankly.

“You know, the one with the story about the insane asylum.”

Jennifer had put the man completely out of her mind. He obviously was someone in need of psychiatric help.

“Tell him to—” She sighed. “Never mind. I’ll tell him myself.”

She picked up the telephone. “Jennifer Parker.”

The familiar voice said, “Did you check the information I gave you?”

“I haven’t had a chance.” She remembered she had thrown away the notes she had made. “I’d like to help you. Will you give me your name?”

“I can’t,” he whispered. “They’ll come after me, too. You just check it out. Helen Cooper. Long Island.”

“I can recommend a doctor who—” The line went dead.

Jennifer sat there a moment, thinking, and then asked Ken Bailey to come into the office.

“What’s up, Chief?”

“Nothing—I think. I’ve had a couple of crank calls from someone who won’t leave his name. Would you please see if you can find out anything about a woman named Helen Cooper. She’s supposed to have had a large estate on Long Island.”

“Where is she now?”

“Either in some insane asylum or on Mars.”

Two hours later, Ken Bailey walked in and surprised Jennifer by saying, “Your Martian has landed. There’s a Helen Cooper committed at The Heathers Asylum in Westchester.”

“Are you sure?” Ken Bailey looked hurt. “I didn’t mean that,” Jennifer said. Ken was the best investigator she had ever known. He never said anything unless he was positive of it, and he never got his facts wrong.

“What’s our interest in the lady?” Ken asked.

“Someone thinks she’s been framed into the asylum. I’d like you to check out her background. I want to know about her family.”

The information was on Jennifer’s desk the following morning. Helen Cooper was a dowager who had been left a fortune of four million dollars by her late husband. Her daughter had married the superintendent of the building where they lived and, six months after the marriage, the bride and groom had gone to court to ask that the mother be declared incompetent, and that the estate be put under their control. They had found three psychiatrists who had testified to Helen Cooper’s incompetency and the court had committed her to the asylum.

Jennifer finished reading the report and looked up at Ken
Bailey. “The whole thing sounds a little fishy, doesn’t it?”

“Fishy? You could wrap it up in a newspaper and serve it with chips. What are you going to do about it?”

It was a difficult question. Jennifer had no client. If Mrs. Cooper’s family had had her locked away, they certainly would not welcome Jennifer’s interference, and since the woman herself had been declared insane, she was not competent to hire Jennifer. It was an interesting problem. One thing Jennifer knew: Client or not, she was not going to stand by and see someone railroaded into an insane asylum. “I’m going to pay a visit to Mrs. Cooper,” Jennifer decided.

The Heathers Asylum was located in Westchester in a large, wooded area. The grounds were fenced in and the only access was through a guarded gate. Jennifer was not yet ready to let the family know what she was doing, so she had telephoned around until she had found an acquaintance with a connection to the sanatorium. He had made arrangements for her to pay a visit to Mrs. Cooper.

The head of the asylum, Mrs. Franklin, was a dour, hard-faced woman who reminded Jennifer of Mrs. Danvers in
Rebecca.

“Strictly speaking,” Mrs. Franklin sniffed, “I should not be letting you talk to Mrs. Cooper. However, we’ll call this an unofficial visit. It won’t go in the records.”

“Thank you.”

“I’ll have her brought in.”

Helen Cooper was a slim, attractive-looking woman in her late sixties. She had vivid blue eyes that blazed with intelligence, and she was as gracious as though she were receiving Jennifer in her own home.

“It was good of you to come and visit me,” Mrs. Cooper said, “but I’m afraid I’m not quite sure why you’re here.”

“I’m an attorney, Mrs. Cooper. I received two anonymous telephone calls telling me you were in here and that you didn’t belong here.”

Mrs. Cooper smiled gently. “That must have been Albert.”

“Albert?”

“He was my butler for twenty-five years. When my daughter, Dorothy, married, she fired him.” She sighed. “Poor Albert. He really belongs to the past, to another world. I suppose, in a sense, I do too. You’re very young, my dear, so perhaps you’re not aware of how much things have changed. Do you know what’s missing today? Graciousness. It’s been replaced, I’m afraid, by greed.”

Jennifer asked quietly, “Your daughter?”

Mrs. Cooper’s eyes saddened. “I don’t blame Dorothy. It’s her husband. He’s not a very attractive man, not morally, at least. I’m afraid my daughter is not very attractive physically. Herbert married Dorothy for her money and found out that the estate was entirely in my hands. He didn’t like that.”

“Did he say that to you?”

“Oh, yes indeed. My son-in-law was quite open about it. He thought I should give my daughter the estate then, instead of making her wait until I died. I would have, except that I didn’t trust him. I knew what would happen if he ever got his hands on all that money.”

“Have you ever had any history of mental illness, Mrs. Cooper?”

Helen Cooper looked at Jennifer and said wryly, “According to the doctors, I’m suffering from schizophrenia and paranoia.”

Jennifer had the feeling that she had never spoken to a more sane person in her life.

“You are aware that three doctors testified that you were incompetent?”

“The Cooper estate is valued at four million dollars, Miss Parker. You can influence a lot of doctors for that kind of
money. I’m afraid you’re wasting your time. My son-in-law controls the estate now. He’ll never let me leave here.”

“I’d like to meet your son-in-law.”

The Plaza Towers was on East 72nd Street, in one of the most beautiful residential areas of New York. Helen Cooper had her own penthouse there. Now the name plate on the door read
Mr. and Mrs. Herbert Hawthorne.

Jennifer had telephoned ahead to the daughter, Dorothy, and when Jennifer arrived at the apartment, both Dorothy and her husband were waiting for her. Helen Cooper had been right about her daughter. She was not attractive. She was thin and mousy-looking, with no chin, and her right eye had a cast in it. Her husband, Herbert, looked like a clone of Archie Bunker. He was at least twenty years older than Dorothy.

“Come on in,” he grunted.

He escorted Jennifer from the reception hall into an enormous living room, the walls of which were covered with paintings by French and Dutch masters.

Hawthorne said to Jennifer bluntly, “Now, suppose you tell me what the hell this is all about.”

Jennifer turned to the girl. “It’s about your mother.”

“What about her?”

“When did she first start showing signs of insanity?”

“She—”

Herbert Hawthorne interrupted. “Right after Dorothy and me got married. The old lady couldn’t stand me.”

That’s certainly one proof of sanity,
Jennifer thought.

“I read the doctors’ reports,” Jennifer said. “They seemed biased.”

“What do you mean, biased?” His tone was truculent.

“What I mean is that the reports indicated that they were dealing in gray areas where there were no clear-cut criteria for establishing what society calls sanity. Their decision was
shaped, in part, by what you and your wife told them about Mrs. Cooper’s behavior.”

“What are you tryin’ to say?”

“I’m saying that the evidence is not clear-cut. Three other doctors could have come up with an entirely different conclusion.”

“Hey, look,” Herbert Hawthorne said, “I dunno what you think you’re tryin’ to pull, but the old lady’s a looney. The doctors said so and the court said so.”

“I read the court transcript,” Jennifer replied. “The court also suggested that her case be periodically reviewed.”

There was consternation on Herbert Hawthorne’s face. “You mean they might let her out?”

“They’re
going
to let her out,” Jennifer promised. “I’m going to see to it.”

“Wait a minute! What the hell is goin’ on here?”

“That’s what I intend to find out.” Jennifer turned to the girl. “I checked out your mother’s previous medical history. There has never been anything wrong with her, mentally or emotionally. She—”

Herbert Hawthorne interrupted. “That don’t mean a damn thing! These things can come on fast. She—”

“In addition,” Jennifer continued to Dorothy, “I checked on your mother’s social activities before you had her put away. She lived a completely normal life.”

“I don’t care what you or anybody else says. She’s crazy!” Herbert Hawthorne shouted.

Jennifer turned to him and studied him a moment. “Did you ask Mrs. Cooper to give the estate to you?”

“That’s none of your goddamned business!”

“I’m making it my business. I think that’s all for now.” Jennifer moved toward the door.

Herbert Hawthorne stepped in front of her, blocking her way. “Wait a minute. You’re buttin’ in where you’re not
wanted. You’re lookin’ to make a little cash for yourself, right? Okay, I understand that, honey. Tell you what I’ll do. Why don’t I give you a check right now for a thousand dollars for services rendered and you just drop this whole thing. Huh?”

“Sorry,” Jennifer replied. “No deal.”

“You think you’re gonna get more from the old lady?”

“No,” Jennifer said. She looked him in the eye. “Only one of us is in this for the money.”

It took six weeks of hearings and psychiatric consultations and conferences with four different state agencies. Jennifer brought in her own psychiatrists and when they were finished with their examinations and Jennifer had laid out all the facts at her disposal, the judge reversed his earlier decision and Helen Cooper was released and her estate restored to her control.

The morning of Mrs. Cooper’s release she telephoned Jennifer.

“I want to take you to lunch at Twenty-One.”

Jennifer looked at her calendar. She had a crowded morning, a luncheon date and a busy afternoon in court, but she knew how much this meant to the elderly woman. “I’ll be there,” Jennifer said.

Helen Cooper’s voice was pleased. “We’ll have a little celebration.”

The luncheon went beautifully. Mrs. Cooper was a thoughtful hostess, and obviously they knew her well at 21.

Jerry Berns escorted them to a table upstairs, where they were surrounded by beautiful antiques and Georgian silver. The food and service were superb.

Helen Cooper waited until they were having their coffee.
Then she said to Jennifer, “I’m very grateful to you, my dear. I don’t know how large a fee you were planning to charge, but I want to give you something more.”