Read The Arrogance of Power Online
Authors: Anthony Summers
Perfidy over the Vietnam War?
36.
Anna Chennault said Nixon asked her to carry messages to South Vietnam's President Thieu during the l968 campaign.
37.
President Johnson received Nixon at the White House after the election, but reportedly believed he had sabotaged the peace initiative.
38.
On the way to victory in l968âthe trademark pose.
39.
January 1969: inaugurated as the thirty-seventh president of the United States.
He can't help it. He must always have a crusade. . . . So I said to our dog Checkers this morning, “Well, Checkers, here we go again. I am once more a candidate's wife and proud to be one.”
âPat, in 1962, weeks before her husband reportedly beat her up
T
he damage from Richard Nixon's loss in the 1960 presidential election went beyond politics. In 1961, journalists in search of a “human interest story” got more than they bargained for. On the day the moving van was being loaded for the family's return to California, Pat suddenly came rushing out of the house. She was “screaming like a banshee,” recalled Washington
Daily News
reporter Tom Kelly, “completely out of control. Her hair was disheveled, her face red, and her eyes were wild.”
Kelly and an Associated Press colleague quickly discovered that it was they who were the targets of Pat's rage. She stood cursing them, claiming that a hostile press had caused her husband's defeat, until Nixon himself appeared. “She had just snapped,” Kelly said. “Nixon had to lead her back into the house, apologizing to us all the while. . . .”
This was a Pat the public had never seen, a Pat embittered by the experience of the previous year. “I've given up everything I loved,” she had said even before the campaign, referring to the loss of privacy and family time. “Mother took the defeat even harder than he did,” her daughter Julie would recall. Years later Pat, like her husband, would still be insisting, “We won in 1960, but the election was stolen from us.”
The months afterward, Julie said, marked a “turning point in my mother's attitude toward politics. 1960 disillusioned her beyond redemption.” What Julie did not reveal was what other intimates noted: that much of Pat's rage was directed against her husband, the husband who had ignored her appeals to quit politics. Even when Nixon had been in the hospital after the knee injury, Pat had not exuded sympathy. “Pat, who seems to feel that Dick is having a wonderful jolly time in the hospital,” Jim Bassett noted in a letter home, “is in one of her âmoods.' . . . nobody else in the U.S. would believe it, would they?”
In early 1961 before leaving the capital, the couple took a vacation in the Bahamas, planned to last a month but cut short by Nixon after two weeks. “The shallow talk, the lack of interest in subjects of importance,” he remembered, “grew more and more boring. . . . I could hardly wait to get back to work.”
Pat and the children spent the next six months in Washington, “in limbo,” as she put it, while Nixon began work with a Los Angeles law firm. “To be alone,” he would recall, he rented a “small bachelor apartment” in which he learned to fix TV dinnersânot mentioning the fact that the apartment was at a very exclusive address across from the Ambassador Hotel.
When the rest of the family reached California, they lived first in a borrowed mansion, then in a house they built in Bel Air. The new home had a panoramic view of the city, four bedrooms, a library, guest and servants' quarters, a swimming pool, and a bathroom for every day of the week. The Nixons' new neighbors included Groucho Marx, Dinah Shore, and the actor Cesar Romero.
More interesting than the house itself was the property's cost and ownership background. The regular listed price for the lot had been $104,250, about $600,000 at today's rates, but Nixon paid only $35,000 because, the real estate agent explained, “he was a celebrity who would spur sales.”
The development on which the property was located was owned by Texas oil tycoon Clint Murchison, a campaign contributor who had long wooed Nixon with gifts and hosted him at his luxury retreat south of Los Angeles. Murchison had purchased the development with financing from the Teamsters Union pension fund, soon to be the subject of a criminal probe. Only months before Nixon bought the house, of course, Teamsters leader Hoffa had been the conduit for a massive Mafia contribution to Nixon's campaign chest.
“After eight years in Washington,” Nixon was to tell Charles Colson, “I left the White House with $38,000 in my savings account and a four-year-old Oldsmobile. Don't you make that mistake.” If that accounting was true, Nixon improved his financial situation rapidly. Back in 1946 Earl Adams, senior partner in a top Los Angeles law firm and one of his original supporters, had guaranteed him a job should he fail to win a seat in Congress. Now that Nixon had missed the most glittering of all political prizes, Adams made good on the promise, handing Nixon a position worth one hundred thousand dollars a year. Nixon was also given a large percentage of any business he brought to the
firm and also had income from writing contracts. The first contract alone was worth forty thousand dollars.
These were riches indeed in 1961. After twelve months, having installed a butler named Reevesâa moniker as close as a man could wish to Jeevesâat home and having purchased a sleek new convertible to convey him around Los Angeles, Nixon was able to give his family even better news. He had made $350,000 that year, the equivalent of $2 million today, more than the total of all his earnings as a politician since 1946. Pat's response was to throw up her hands and cry “Hallelujah!”
On the surface all seemed well with the Nixons in the late summer of 1961. Friends said they had never seen Pat so relaxed and apparently happy. One close friend, however, the writer Adela Rogers St. Johns, overheard a searing quarrel between husband and wife. “If you ever run for office again,” the Nixons' old confidante recalled Pat threatening, “I'll kill myself.”
As one who had been close to the family for years, St. Johns thought the threat sounded genuine. Yet running for office again was exactly what Nixon intended.
1
_____
Nixon had never truly abandoned politics, nor politics him. Within twenty-four hours of leaving the vice presidency, when he had left for the vacation in the Bahamas, his hosts had been a former assistant secretary of defense and a property magnate. Nixon named them in his memoirs as Perkins McGuire and Lindsay Hopkins, without identifying them. In fact, McGuire owned Southern Air Transport, a “spook airline” that had for months been flying CIA missions in the secret war against Castro, while Hopkins was a director of Zenith Technical Enterprises, the main dummy company that provided cover for the CIA's massive anti-Castro operation in Florida.
Three months later, over drinks at Nixon's Washington house, a distraught Allen Dulles told him that the Cuba project was about to end in disaster at the Bay of Pigs. Nixon's daughter Tricia, now fifteen, left a message by the telephone in the hall the following day: “J.F.K. called. I knew it! It wouldn't be long before he would get into trouble and have to call on you for help.
We have only Nixon's account of what passed between the two men when they discussed Cuba later in the Oval Office. A biographer who saw his contemporary notes reported that Nixon wrote at the top of the page that Kennedy had “said âshit' six times!” The president was furious at what he viewed as the useless assurances he had been given about the invasion and called the debacle “the worst experience of my life.”
Nixon's published account of the meeting makes no mention of matters that must surely have been covered, including the exile politics in which Nixon had dabbled and the CIA activity to which he had been privy. Least of all did he mention the plots to kill Castro, of which both men were probably aware.
After leaving the White House, Nixon made numerous calls to fellow Republicans, cajoling, even threatening them, not to attack Kennedy over the Bay of Pigs. It is not likely he did so in a burst of fellow feeling. Nixon well knew that a full exposure of the poor decisions, misadventures, and conspiracies that had led to the Bay of Pigs would indicate that all had had their genesis in the previous administration and that he had been involved.
Whatever the potential risk, however, Nixon himself would soon enough find an opportunity to criticize Kennedy's Cuba policy. In the short term he contented himself with declaring publicly that the United States “should not start things in the world unless we are prepared to finish them.” Later he would shift to, “Jack handled Cuba badly.” In his memoirs he would insist it was Kennedy who “doomed the operation” by withholding air support. As late as 1992 he would be lashing out at the dead president on the subject in a bizarre way yet to be explained. “Do you think he ran the Bay of Pigs plan past Congress?” he asked. “Or his plans to knock off Castro? Money changed hands on that score, don't fool yourself.”
After Eisenhower's death Nixon would heap blame on him as well, reportedly telling Henry Kissinger in a 1970 memo that Eisenhower had “let Cuba go down the drain.” He was to state six years later that he would have gone in with whatever force was necessary to win, “probably in the last month of 1960. . . . I was hard line on Cuba and would have wanted to go ahead without delay.”
The only way to have provided “the force necessary to win” by December would have been to mount a full-scale American invasionâprobably some sixty thousand troops strongâand advance planning for such an operation would have to have started many weeks earlier.
2
For a multitude of political reasons, this option seems to have been rejectedâexcept perhaps by Nixon. He later recalled telling Kennedy after the Bay of Pigs that had he been president, he would have found “a proper legal cover”ânamely, a pretextâto invade Cuba. Kennedy replied that he could not have risked provoking the Soviet Union with such an action.
Criticism of Kennedy's management of the Bay of Pigs is said to have been especially strong within the CIA. It is instructive, then, to discover that the man who headed the CIA's preparations, Cuba Task Force head Jacob Esterline, assigned the blame not so much to Kennedy as to Richard Nixon.
“It is very wrong to pick too much on Jack Kennedy,” Esterline said in 1975 in a taped interview for a CIA in-house history. Both then and in a 1998 interview, the former task force chief faulted Nixon for having put selfish political motives above operational priorities. “It came down to us by way of Dulles,” Esterline explained, that it was Nixon who had “canceled the timetable.” In the weeks before the Nixon-Kennedy election, in November 1960, CIA trainers had still been working on the insertion of guerrilla teams into a region of Cuba where they were likely to have strong popular support and where
it was hoped that they could start a groundswell of counterrevolution to topple the Castro regime.
“It might not have worked,” Esterline said, “but it would not have been a major disaster. It would just have been another little thing. . . . But I am told Nixon thought, âWell, they had better wait until the election before they mounted anything of the sort.' . . . Nixon may have thought that, with the action taking placeâespecially if not successfulâthe resultant fallout might negatively affect his presidential aspirations. . . . And after he lost the election, they felt they didn't know whether they wanted to do it or not. The end was that it just kept escalating and turning into the nightmares that became the Bay of Pigs, which they then dumped on Jack Kennedy's lap.”
3
“Of course,” Nixon was still complaining in rancorous old age, President Kennedy “was never held accountable” for the Bay of Pigs. Nor of course was Nixon himself. History may one day change that if the full CIA record has been preserved. Until we know more, the “Bay of Pigs thing” Nixon was to fret about as president must mark his reputation as least as much as it did that of John F. Kennedy.
4
_____
The perks of life as a top-flight attorney had rapidly palled for Nixon. “I found it difficult to concentrate,” he recalled, “almost impossible to work up much enthusiasm.” Nixon missed Washington, so much so that he commissioned a weekly report on goings-on in the capital. As titular head of the Republican party he crisscrossed the country making speeches. He also set about writing a book.
This was
Six Crises,
Nixon's personal account of his political career, from the Hiss case to his defeat at Kennedy's hands, presented as the self-portrait of a battler against life's tough odds. Producing the book, he claimed in its introduction, was such a great ordeal that it rated as “the seventh major crisis of my life.” Told of a weeklong session during which Nixon “barricaded himself with groceries, long yellow pads, a tape recorder and reels of tape,” one reporter wrote in awed tones of his “fierce self-discipline.”
In a new 1990 edition of
Six Crises,
Nixon credited two colleagues with “editorial and research assistance” but gave the impression that most of the writing had been his. One of these colleagues, his former special assistant Alvin Moscow, said in 1998, “I was hired, I wrote the first five chapters, of the total of six. Nixon didn't want to go over each one. . . . Between you and me I thought I'd been had. He waited until I'd written the whole thing, and then he went back and put in a lot of his Nixonian expressions. . . . The sixth chapter he did write, the one on the election of 1960.”
Nixon's friend Adela Rogers St. Johns also claimed to have done much of the writing. Years later, when the author Seymour Hersh asked Nixon for an advance blurb on one of his books, a spokesman phoned with regrets. “Mr.
Nixon,” he said, “only comments on his own books, the ones written for him.”
Six Crises
was not written merely for the financial rewardâNixon received an estimated advance of $345,000 in 1962 dollars, which he agreed was “too much, really”âbut with a shrewd eye to timing. The book was to be published in the spring of 1962, touted as “the mature wisdom and courage of a great American statesman,” and sent to political writers throughout California just as Nixon embarked on a new political campaign. Dropping any pretense that the attorney's job was more than a stopgap, he had begun running for governor of the state against the Democratic incumbent, Edmund (“Pat”) Brown.