The Puzzle of Left-Handedness (34 page)

38

Creative, Musical, Brilliant and Famous!

‘Is your child left-handed? Then maybe you’re raising a genius’, ran a headline in the British magazine
The Listener
in 1975. It was one of those articles in which enormous creativity and remarkable artistic gifts are attributed to left-handers, based on the supposed dominance of that emotional, creative right half of the brain. The value of ideas like this is of course only relative, even though they may come as a welcome relief to left-handers after a whole series of negative dictums, an attitude of incomprehension on the part of parents and teachers, and ominous messages à la Stanley Coren. It’s often mentioned that not only the mentally handicapped but geniuses include an unexpectedly large number of left-handers. But what does this mean, if no one knows just how many geniuses the world has produced? People regularly point to famous left-handers of the past, such as Michelangelo and Leonardo da Vinci. In many cases, incidentally, this appeal to genius is based on shifting sand, since an enthusiasm for claiming prominent individuals for the left-hander camp often gets the better of conscientiousness. Bob Dylan is not left-handed, and neither was Picasso, nor a whole string of other celebrated figures. This kind of thing serves no purpose anyhow, since it would be equally justifiable and equally ill-conceived to comfort bald men who have birthmarks with the achievements of Mikhail Gorbachev, disabled people with the success of Stephen Hawking or depressive redheads with the genius of Vincent van Gogh.

Innumerable well-worn tales are told about architecture colleges and music academies where a fantastically high proportion of left-handers is to be found, and they’re said to get better marks on average too. Anything is possible, but we have no solid data to suggest left-handedness is accompanied by special gifts. Only in two areas do left-handers undeniably have an advantage.

One is in sports like tennis, baseball, boxing and fencing. But then again, they’re at a disadvantage in games like polo and hockey.

The other is the us presidency. Bizarrely, that tiny, illustrious company of men includes an improbable number of left-handers. Of the last seven presidents, up to and including Barack Obama, five were left-handed, the exceptions being Jimmy Carter and George W. Bush. The Republican candidate for the 2008 election, John McCain, is also a member of the club, while in 1992 the sitting president, Bush senior, and both his challengers, Bill Clinton and Ross Perot, were left-handed. Still, does this say anything about left-handedness in general? If it does, then it can’t be anything particularly complimentary, since nice people could never hope to triumph in the ruthless contest that is the race for the American presidency. We’re talking here about such an exceptional group of people anyhow that it’s safe to assume little can be deduced from the statistics.

Left-handers seem, as far as we can tell, simply to be left-handed. In a predominantly right-handed world they are generally presented with misleading examples to follow, unhelpful instructions and less than optimal tools. In many ways this throws them back on their own resources from a young age. Perhaps left-handed people should at least be allowed to flatter themselves with the thought that they’re more independent than average.

Charlie Chaplin playing the cello with his left hand,
c.
1915.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Achbar, M., ed. 1995
Manufacturing Consent: Noam Chomsky and the Media
, Montreal, Black Rose Books

Altera, J. 1970 ‘Wat doen we eigenlijk voor uitgesproken linkshandigen’,
Pedagogische Studiën

Anderson, M. G. 1989 ‘Lateral preference and longevity’,
Nature

Annett, M. 1972 ‘The distribution of manual asymmetry’,
British Journal of Psychology

—, 1974 ‘Handedness in children of two left-handed parents’,
British Journal of Psychology

—, 1975 ‘Hand preference and the laterality of cerebral speech’,
Cortex

—, 1976 ‘A coordination of hand preference and skill replicated’,
British Journal of Psychology

—, 1985
Left, Right, Hand and Brain: The right shift theory
, London, Lawrence Erlbaum

—, and M. Manning 1989 ‘The disadvantages of dextrality for intelligence’,
British Journal of Psychology

Apuleius, L. 2003
De gouden ezel (metamorfosen), vertaald en toegelicht door Vincent Hunink
, Amsterdam, Athenaeum – Polak & Van Gennep

Bächtold-Stäubli, H. 1987
Handwörterbuch des deutschen Aberglaubes
, Berlin, De Gruyter

Bakan, P. 1973 ‘Handedness and alcoholism’,
Perceptual and Motor Skills

Bakan, P., G. Dibb and P. Reed 1973 ‘Handedness and birth stress’,
Neuropsychologia

Bambach, C. C. 2003
Leonardo, Left-Handed Draftsman and Writer
, New York, The Metropolitan Museum of Art

Barnes, F. 1975 ‘Temperament, adaptability and left-handers’,
New Scientist

Barsley, M. 1968
Linkshandigheid: wetenswaardigheden en curiosa voor links- en rechtshandigen
, Hilversum, Haan

Barsley, M. 1970
Left-Handed Man in a Right-Handed World
, London, Pitman

Baskerville, R. F. 1992 ‘On the directional asymmetry of rhesus macaque forelimb bones’,
American Journal of Physical Anthropology

Bellugi, U., E. S. Klima et al. 1986
Examining Language Dominance Through Hand Dominance
, Boston University Conference on Language Development

Belmont, L., and H. S. Birch 1963 ‘Lateral Dominance and Right-Left Awareness in Normal Children’,
Child Development

Benbow, C. P. 1986 ‘Physiological Correllates of Extreme Intellectual Precocity’,
Neuropsychologia

Benton, A. L. 1959
Right-Left Discrimination and Finger Localization
, New York, Hoeber-Harper

—, R. Meyers and G. Polder 1962 ‘Some aspects of handedness’,
Psychiatric Neurology

Best, C. T. 1985
Hemispheric Function and Collaboration in the Child
, New York, Academic Press

Bever, T. G., and R. J. Chiarello 1974 ‘Cerebral dominance in musicians and nonmusicians’,
Science

Birkett, P. 1979 ‘Relationships among handedness, familial handedness, sex and ocular sighting-dominance’,
Neuropsychologia

Bisazza, A., et al. 1996 ‘Right-pawedness in toads’,
Nature

Bishop, D.V.M. 1983 ‘How sinister is sinistrality?’
Journal of the Royal College of Physicians of London

—, 1989 ‘Does hand proficiency determine hand preference?’
British Journal of Psychology

—, 1989 ‘On the futility of using familial sinistrality to subclassify handedness groups’,
Cortex

—, 1990
Handedness and Developmental Disorder
, London, MacKeith

Blakeslee, T. R. 1980
The Right Brain
, London, MacMillan

Blau, A. 1946
The Master Hand: A study of right and left sidedness and its relation to laterality and language
, Research Monographs of the American Orthopsychiatric Association

—, 1961 ‘Don’t let your child be a leftie!’
Lakeland Ledger,
5 March

Bock, G. R., and J. Marsh, eds 1991
Biological Asymmetry and Handedness
, New York, Wiley

Boklage, C. E. 1981 ‘On the distribution of non-right-handedness among twins and their families’,
Acta geneticae medicae et gemellologiae

—, 1984 ‘Twinning, handedness, and the biology of symmetry’, in Geschwind and Galaburda 1984

Bouma, J. M. 1988
Perceptual Asymmetries and Hemispheric Specialization
, diss., Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam

Bourassa, D. C., I. C. McManus and M. P. Bryden 1996 ‘Handedness and eye dominance: A meta-analysis of their relationship’,
Laterality

Bradshaw, J. L. 1980 ‘Right-hemisphere language: Familial and non-familial sinistrals, cognitive deficits and writing hand position in sinistrals, and concrete abstract, imageable-nonimageable dimensions in word recognition. A review of interrelated issues’,
Brain and Language

Bradshaw, J. L., and N. Nettleton 1983
Human Cerebral Asymmetry
, Hemel Hempstead, Prentice Hall

Briggs, G. G., and R. D. Nebes 1976 ‘The effects of handedness, family history and sex on the performance of a dichotic listening task’,
Neuropsychologia

Brightwell, R. 1975 ‘Is your child left-handed? Then you may be bringing up a genius’,
The Listener,
7 February

Bryden, M. P. 1973 ‘Perceptual asymmetry in vision: Relation to handedness, eyedness and speech lateralization’,
Cortex

Burt, C. 1937
The Backward Child
, University of London Press

Calnan, M., and K. Richardson 1976 ‘Developmental correlates of handedness in a national sample of 11-year-olds’ (National Children’s Bureau, London)
Annals of Human Biology

Carlyle, T. 1837
The French Revolution: A History in Three Volumes
, Boston, Charles C. Little and James Brown

Carroll, L. 1872
Through the Looking Glass, and What Alice Found There
, London, MacMillan

Casasanto, D. 2009 ‘Embodiment of abstract concepts: good and bad in right- and left-handers’,
Journal of Experimental Psychology

—, R. Willems and P. Hagoort 2010 ‘Body-specific representations of action verbs: evidence from fMRI in right- and left-handers’,
Psychological Science

Castillo, G. A. 1974
Left-Handed Teaching: Lessons in affective education
, New York, Praeger

CBS
1986 ‘Linkshandigheid’,
Maandbericht Gezondheidsstatistiek

Chamberlain, H. D. 1928 ‘The inheritance of left-handedness’,
Journal of Heredity

Clark, K. 1939
Leonardo da Vinci
, London, Penguin

Clark, M. M. 1957
Left-Handedness: Laterality characteristics and their educational implications
, University of London Press

—, 1980
Linkshandige kinderen: onderzoek en praktijk
, Nijkerk, Intro

Cole, J. 1955 ‘Paw preference in cats related to hand preference in animals and man’,
Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology

Collins, R. L. 1968/69 ‘On the heredity of handedness’,
Journal of Heredity

Conrad, K. 1949 ‘Über aphasischen Sprachstörungen bei hirnverletzten Linkshänder’,
Der Nervenarzt

Corballis, M. C. 1983
Human Laterality
, New York, Academic Press

—, and I. L. Beale 1971 ‘On telling left from right’,
Scientific American

—, and —, 1976
The Psychology of Left and Right
, New Jersey, L. Erlbaum

Coren, S. 1989 ‘Left-handedness and accident-related injury risk’,
American Journal of Public Health

—, 1992
The Left-Hander Syndrome: The causes and consequences of left-handedness
, London, John Murray

—, and D. Halpern 1991 ‘Left-handedness: A marker for decreased survival fitness’,
Psychological Bulletin

—, and —, 1991 ‘Hand preference and life span’,
New England Journal of Medicine

—, ed. 1990
Left-Handedness: Behavioral implications and anomalies
, Amsterdam, North-Holland

—, A. Searleman and C. Porac 1986 ‘Rate of physical maturation and handedness’,
Developmental Neuropsychology

Coryell, J. F., and G. F. Michel 1978 ‘How supine postural preferences of infants can contribute toward the development of handedness’,
Infant Behaviour and Development

Coulmas, F. 1989
The Writing Systems of the World
, Oxford, Basil Blackwell

Crovitz, H. F. 1962 ‘On direction in drawing a person’,
Journal of Consult Psychology

Dart, R. 1949 ‘The predatory implemental technique of Australopithecus’,
American Journal of Physical Anthropology

Dawson, J. 1972 ‘Temne-Arunta hand-eye dominance and cognitive style’,
Journal of Psychology

Deglin, V. L. 1976 ‘Our split brain’,
The
UNESCO
Courier,
January

DeKay, J. T. 1966
The Left Handed Book
, New York, Evans

Demarest, J., and L. Demarest 1980 ‘Does the torque test measure cerebral dominance in adults?’
Perceptual and Motor Skills

Dennis, W. 1958 ‘Early Graphic Evidence of Dextrality in Man’,
Perceptual and Motor Skills

Dimond, S. J., and D. A. Blizard 1977
Evolution and Lateralization of the Brain
, New York Academy of Science

Draaisma, Douwe 2004 ‘Het einde van de hersenverdoving’,
AMC
-magazine,
October

Duffy, F. H., G. B. McAnulty and S. C. Schachter 1984 ‘Brain Electrical Activity Mapping’, in Geschwind and Galaburda 1984

Dumont, J. J. 1976
Leerstoornissen
, vols 1 and 2, Rotterdam, Lemniscaat

Eling, P. 1987 ‘Waarom is rechts schrijven toch beter dan links?’
Jeugd, School en Wereld

—, and B. Vreede-Chabot 1989 ‘Is ons schrift gemaakt voor de rechter-hand?’
Tijdschrift voor orthopedagogiek

Ellis, S. J., et al. 1998 ‘Is forced dextrality an explanation for the fall in the prevalence of sinistrality with age? A study in northern England’,
Journal of Epidemiological Community Health

—, P. J. Ellis and E. Marshall 1988 ‘Hand preference in a normal population’,
Cortex

Engen, A. van 1980
Leerkrachten en handigheidskeuze. Een inventariserend onderzoek naar de handigheidsproblematiek in klas 1 bij het schrijfonderwijs
, Groningen

—, 1981
Nota Schrijfdidactiek voor Linkshandigen
, Assen,
SABD
Drente

—, 1982
Schrijfdidactiek voor Linkshandigen
, Informatiepunt Basisonderwijs no. 170

Ettlinger, G., and A. Moffett 1964 ‘Lateral Preferences in the Monkey’,
Nature

Finch, G. 1941 ‘Chimpanzees’ Handedness’,
Science

Fincher, J. 1993
Lefties
, New York, Barnes and Noble

Flament, F. 1975
Coordination et prevalence manuelle chez le nourri
sson, Aix, Eds
CNRS