Lisa’s Story
I discovered pretty early on that I loved school. I even remember loving my first homework assignment, to write my name four times. Some of my earliest friends were books. The storybooks I read as a child still sit on my shelves so I can look at them and smile, remembering the great adventures they brought me without having to leave my bedroom. In seventh grade, my English teacher inscribed my yearbook,
“To Lisa, my most inquisitive student, but you were a delight.”
After I looked up the word “inquisitive,” knew what she really meant: “Lisa, you interrupted me constantly with questions, but I liked you anyway.” Some things never change. ■
ask yourself
1.
How important is learning to you?
2.
Did you take school seriously when you were there? Do you regret it if not?
3.
Do you read the newspaper every day to keep yourself constantly learning?
4.
How often do you read an entire book?
5.
Do you have a social group that enjoys learning, like a book group or a continuing-education class?
The Rabbi
A rabbi is not like a priest. A priest is usually considered an intermediary between the ordinary people and God. In the Catholic faith, the ultimate priest is the pope, and he is considered by the faithful to be “infallible.” Jews have no such person in their faith. Our rabbis are merely teachers—hopefully learned, ethical teachers, but teachers nonetheless. They are considered no closer to God than anyone else. We also use the term “rabbi” to mean a mentor in business; in other words, a person who is looking out for you and teaching you what you need to know to succeed.
As a teacher, the rabbi is revered in the Jewish community. Why? Because he is presumed to know the most. Knowledge is a sacred value.
ABC . . . Easy as 1,2,3 ...
Jewish mothers believe it is never too early to teach the basics. From the minute we find out we are pregnant, we talk to our children, surrounding them with educational toys, books and music. Don’t laugh—Lisa swears both her kids recognized “Edelweiss” from the womb. Read to your children from the day they are born. Don’t be put off by thinking your baby can’t understand
Winnie
the
Pooh
yet; none of us know how early our kids begin to understand language. The point is to lay the foundation early for your child to love reading. He will surely love reading if you have begun that experience as a bond together from his earliest memory.
A Word on Television:
Ah, the ubiquitous boob tube. We admit it—we love our television. Gloria and Jill particularly love theirs, and Lisa would find it difficult to survive without classic movies, shown without commercial interruptions. But watching television is no substitute for the experience of reading a book, and you are kidding yourself if you think your child is learning more from a video than he would if he sat on your lap and you read a story to him, one-on-one. Sure, it takes time and patience to read to your child, but we Jewish mothers cannot stress enough how important it is to teach your children by example that book learning is the number one way for a person to absorb information. Lisa was so fed up with fighting about this issue that she and Bill decided to remove all television connections from the home for the entire family. This experiment lasted two years, until the next Olympics, when they kept their promise to televise this occasion. Naturally, the television stayed, but this time, with strict limits. What had been accomplished? Plenty. Jon became an avid reader for life, during the crucial ages of seven to nine, and Joanna benefited as well, living in a house without television from the ages of one through three. You want your kids to be readers? Hide the clicker.
Gloria’s Kvelling
We taught Lisa to say her entire alphabet before she was two. I bragged about it to everyone. She also counted on her fingers. We
kvelled.
■
Lisa’s Example
The best baby gift we received for our firstborn was a carton of baby books from our cousin Selma. I read to Jon for hours every day in his rocking chair. At two, he could recite his name, address and phone number in case he got lost. At four, Jon could read Dr. Seuss’s
Hop
on Pop out loud by himself. We
kvelled.
■
Jill’s Approach
I purposely filmed a scene for the show with Allyson reading the op-ed page of
The New York Times
to identify words she didn’t know and look them up. I wanted to emphasize how important vocabulary is and how we try to integrate it in the home every day. The Jewish mother is always teaching. ■
ask yourself
1.
Are you laying a solid foundation for your children vis-à-vis education?
2.
How many hours do you sit your kid in front of a screen? Turn it off!
3.
How many books are in your house right now? When is the last time you read one?
4.
Do you quiz yourself on the words you don’t know? Do you keep a dictionary handy in the kitchen or eat on a place mat of a map? These are easy and fun ways to keep learning all the time.
Public vs. Private: Which Is Better?
If you are a parent, choosing your child’s school is one of the most important decisions you will make. Just as you were shaped by where you attended school, so too will your child be affected not only by what she learns in the classroom but also by the rules of the playground. Unfortunately, when it comes to education, we don’t get any do-overs. But also remember that kids are resilient; once they find the right environment in which to learn, they will blossom. What is your job as a parent? To find the learning environment that is best for your child.
Which is better: public or private? Our answer: It all depends, and not only on one’s pocketbook. We have friends whose children attend the most elite boarding schools on scholarships; we have others who could afford the most expensive private schools but choose the local public schools. For some families where religious education is paramount, public school is not even an option. The key is to make the decision that is right for your family and your child. First you must evaluate your options.
Jewish mothers are usually experts on the educational choices available in their community for every grade that their own kids have passed through. Ask a Jewish mother about a good preschool, and instead of answers, you will get a series of questions as the interrogation begins: “Are you looking for strong academics, good play space, religious instruction, parental involvement, certified teachers, a nice classroom, a longer day, an anti-bullying program?” These are just some of the factors that skip through her mind in a nanosecond. Really, if you don’t have a Jewish friend yet and you are a parent of kids in school, you ought to go find yourself one. It will save you a lot of legwork.
Second, you need to know your child. You need to balance the pros of keeping your kid on the same school bus as the other neighborhood kids versus the cons of knowing that your kid will now have new friends who are a
shlep
away in other towns, and that your kid may now feel excluded from the after-school games on his own block. You need to decide whether the pros of the particular education your child will get in a specific private school outweigh the cons of the education he is receiving right now. We Jewish mothers are pretty good at figuring out the right questions to ask, but only you know the right answer for your family.
Gloria’s Take
Forty-five years ago the world was a different place. We moved to Woodmere from Brooklyn for the good public schools, and they worked for Lisa. She did well there and got an excellent education. Jill had some problems, and it might have been wiser for us to move her to get a fresh start, but we kept at it and eventually things got better for her. ■
Jill’s Story
We had considered public school for Ally, but private for us in New York City seemed the better option. Someone once told me that the most important thing he could give his children was an education, because it was irreplaceable. He was not Jewish, but it really made an impact on me. We were not rich when I had Allyson and paying for private school in New York City was a big sacrifice. It meant giving up vacations and dinners out and living in a smaller apartment. But it was the best investment I could make for our daughter.
In her current private school, they provide extra help every day from her teachers if needed, and she has a unique one-on-one relationship with all of her teachers. They taught her not just the action of reading but the love of words. She is engaged in her subjects and looks forward to going to class. New York City public schools are overcrowded and hit-or-miss. Walking into an average middle school in New York City means metal detectors and security. There are wonderful public schools with special programs for gifted students, and I would have sent Ally to one if I couldn’t have afforded private school, but I was willing to go without “stuff” before I would do that. ■